Counterpoint: Football represents the worst of American culture – studlife.com

Every fall, stadiums fill, televisions light up, and millions of Americans gather to watch football. The spectacle is undeniable, but beneath the fireworks and Friday night lights is a more uncomfortable truth: Football culture, particularly at the national level, reflects some of the worst aspects of American society — glorified aggression, hypermasculinity, the exploitation of bodies for profit, and unchecked capitalism. Supporters argue that football showcases American greatness, but the reality is that it showcases American excess. 
Football is built around collision: The harder the hit, the louder the crowd. We replay bone-crushing tackles in slow motion and package them into highlight reels (which even I find darkly fascinating). This violence is not incidental to the game, but central to its appeal. America has long wrestled with its fascination with violence as entertainment. Reality television is criticised for exploiting emotional breakdowns. Violent video games are scrutinized for their psychological impact. Yet our culture protects football from this criticism, which often results in broken bones and physical trauma. 
The normalization of violence becomes even more disturbing when paired with research linking football games to increased domestic violence. The National Bureau of Economic Research found that there was a 10% increase in reports of domestic violence by men against their wives and girlfriends after games where the home team lost but was predicted to win. When the emotional outcome of a game correlates with real-world harm, we have to question what kind of culture we are cultivating. 
In addition to the normalization of violence within households, the game itself promotes serious head trauma. For years, the National Football League denied and downplayed the long-term effects of the repetitive head trauma that football players face. Numerous former NFL players have been posthumously diagnosed with Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE), a degenerative brain disease linked to repeated blows to the head. The NFL was aware of these health concerns long before they were made public, and even tried to scare scientists away from studying this disease out of their concern for the league’s image. 
Even after the NFL’s public acknowledgement of CTE and chronic brain injuries, there have been several recent cases of allowing seriously injured players to play. Atlanta Falcons quarterback Tua Tagovailoa is a prime example, as he faced a serious hit that left him seizing in 2022. This hit came two weeks after he experienced a concussion, yet he was cleared to play the following week — just another example of teams and the NFL prioritizing the game over players’ health. 
Defenders of the sport point to changes made by the NFL to improve concussion protocols, and yes, incremental reforms have been made. The fundamental structure of football, however, remains unchanged: Young men (many of whom come from lower-income backgrounds) risk lifelong neurological damage in exchange for entertainment revenue that overwhelmingly benefits owners and networks. This system depends on a constant stream of bodies that are viewed as replaceable. 
Proponents of football might also say that it brings communities together, and, at a local level, that can be true. A high school game on a Friday night or a neighborhood watch party can foster a genuine connection. Nationally, however, football is not primarily about community; it’s about profit. The NFL generates billions annually through broadcasting rights, sponsorships, and merchandise. Stadiums are financed with public funds while franchise valuations soar. The fun “community” game is now a commercialized spectacle. The sense of togetherness we feel while watching does not originate from the billion-dollar football league; it’s from shared meals, conversation, and tradition. 
Football culture in America does not have to reflect exploitation and indifference. It could prioritize player safety over ratings. It could guarantee long-term healthcare for former players. It could shift youth sports away from early high-impact drills and protect the health of young players. It could celebrate skill and strategy rather than highlight reel violence. 
As viewers, we also have power. We can demand accountability from leagues like the NFL and support reforms. We can choose to engage with sports in ways that emphasize inclusivity, joy, and safety over hatred and aggression. We don’t need to remove football from America’s cultural landscape, but we do need to decide what kind of culture we want it to represent. If football is to remain part of American culture, it needs to evolve, and we need to redefine what community, sport, and strength look like to us.
Tags: america, american culture, Football, Sports
Get the latest and top news from StudentLife delivered to your inbox
Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.
[email protected]
Washington University in St. Louis
314-935-5995
© 2023 Washington University Student Media, Inc. – All rights reserved

source