New CDC Policy on Hepatitis B Vaccination Needs a Second Look – Jewish Journal

The Center for Disease Control recently attracted national attention for ending its long-standing recommendation that all newborns receive a standard hepatitis B vaccination. Much less discussion attended a 2022 recommendation from a key CDC advisory committee—which is now being implemented—calling for Hepatitis B vaccinations for all adults ages 19 to 59. Roughly 120 million Americans are newly eligible for the two-to-three-shot vaccinations under the guideline.
Reducing the risk of acute hepatitis B—which produces jaundice and fevers among other symptoms—offers a worthy public health goal. But the main reason for vaccination is to eliminate the life threatening chronic form of the disease, which afflicts roughly 5% of those infected who fail to clear the virus. Much like HIV, the main risk factors are sexual transmission, particularly for men having sex with men, and intravenous drug use with shared needles.
A relative few of my patients have risk of hepatitis B and most of have already been vaccinated. Why would my other patients and the roughly two thirds of Americans between ages 50 and 59 who are married and not intravenous drug users need the vaccine? It’s a fair question and one that the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization (ACIP) glossed over in its recommendation three years ago. ACIP noted that physicians see patients’ willingness to disclose risk factors as a barrier, and many think they have insufficient time to assess risks. In other words, ACIP enables a “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy in which providers won’t need to ask about risk factors and patients don’t have to disclose them. Is that a sound basis for a vaccine recommendation?
Let’s look more closely at the risk issues. For those age 50 to 59, ACIP notes that there has been an increase in the risk of hepatitis B, from 1.1 to 1.6 cases per 100,000. The chances of developing chronic hepatitis B for that group would be just less than one in a million, about equal to the annual risk of being struck by lightning. The chances of dying in an automobile accident in Los Angeles are more than one hundred times greater than this group’s chronic hepatitis B risk. So, the drive across town to get the vaccine may pose more risk than the disease.
I asked a local infectious disease specialist about the recommendations. He advised compliance with the guidelines and noted that we vaccinate against other very low risk conditions. There aren’t many. We do vaccinate against tetanus, which is less common than hepatitis B. However, unlike hepatitis B, tetanus has no easily identified risk factors and is an untreatable condition that is routinely fatal. In an era in which vaccine skepticism based on ignorance is so common, physicians like my colleague may be reluctant to be seen as contributing to the scrum.
The CDC recommendation poses particular problems for primary care doctors like me. Medical systems now track compliance with standard recommendations and insurance report cards may downgrade providers or systems that lag. So offering patients a choice based on their individual risk may be portrayed as sub-standard care. But the issues go beyond the coercive practice of grading providers. A major theme of current medical practice in the wake of COVID-19 is battling unprecedented resistance to critical vaccinations. We already struggle to convince our 50–59-year-olds to stay updated on six different vaccines. Flu vaccine is one example. Despite a national average of 30,000 annual flu-related deaths, we devote precious time and effort to convince vulnerable patients to protect themselves by vaccinating. It helps neither our credibility nor our burgeoning workloads to be compelled to offer yet another vaccine because “that’s the recommendation” or because we don’t trust patients to disclose their risk.
It helps neither our credibility nor our burgeoning workloads to be compelled to offer yet another vaccine because “that’s the recommendation” or because we don’t trust patients to disclose their risk.
The doctors I know resent the actions of the RFK-led CDC in weakening the vaccine mandates that protect Americans’ lives and health. To oppose the hepatitis B recommendation that preceded RFK’s reign might be seen as aiding and abetting the enemy. It’s not. True north for physicians has always been the benefit of the individual patient and the community. The vast majority affected by the hepatitis B recommendations will not benefit. Providing each patient with their own risk and benefit for hepatitis B vaccine should be standard work. When doctors can’t comply with a CDC guidelines in good conscience, the CDC should recognize the need to reconsider this well-intentioned but wrong-headed policy.
Dr. Daniel Stone is Regional Medical Director of Cedars-Sinai Valley Network and a practicing internist and geriatrician with Cedars Sinai Medical Group. The views expressed in this column do not necessarily reflect those of Cedars-Sinai.
What others might perceive as weakness, we should perceive as our calling.
Attacks against Jews keep rising, but this does not mean it is our destiny. Here is what we must do to ensure a thriving Jewish future.
Lior Geller, “The World Will Tremble”’s director, told The Journal he was surprised to discover that no major film had previously been made about the two men.
“On Being Jewish Now” – the book and the show – bring real, personal stories of humor, heartbreak and hope to life.
An upcoming online event organized by American Jewish University (AJU) will explore diverse traditions and the ways they reflect the rich cultural tapestry of Jewish life.
Cohen and Azadeh look toward the future after the war and look forward to visiting each other’s homelands.
It’s the perfect time to celebrate all things carb-y and comforting, especially with Passover fast approaching.
Morocco has always had a deep connection to almonds, where they have grown for centuries and where they are central to many festive foods.
Sacredness Of Life
Attacks against Jews keep rising, but this does not mean it is our destiny. Here is what we must do to ensure a thriving Jewish future.
For the people of Israel, freedom is not the open skies—a world of unlimited and unguarded possibilities. It is the hot and dry slog through the desert, full of prickly rules and regulations.
While the Jewish people continue to face enemies seeking our destruction, we continue to survive.
Between memory and motion lies the work every tradition must perform.
Will the war against Iran turn from a one-time, life-saving surgical operation into ongoing treatment for a chronic disease?
The Kotel does not belong to one denomination or one interpretation of Judaism. It belongs to the Jewish people, in Israel, in the Diaspora, across all movements, backgrounds and traditions.
A number of philosophers, psychologists and other commentators have argued that empathy can actually be harmful.
The anti-hyphen warriors claim to be merely calling out a hate movement.
I encourage you to document the stories of your parents, grandparents, and older loved ones. I wish I’d had the opportunity to sit down with my grandparents and do this.

source